Vladimir Guerrero Jr: MLB Analyst Thinks the Blue Jays Are Out of the Race and Giveaway

Soto’s eventual destination will significantly impact MLB’s competitive balance. If he stays in New York, it could solidify the Yankees or Mets as perennial contenders

If he moves to Toronto, the Blue Jays could become the American League’s newest powerhouse. Alternatively, a surprise suitor could shift the narrative entirely.

His talent, marketability, and potential to transform a franchise ensure that his free agency will be remembered as one of the most consequential in MLB history.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr: The Offseason’s Crown Jewel

Juan Soto, one of the brightest stars in Major League Baseball (MLB), enters this offseason as the most coveted free agent.¹

Fresh off a stellar campaign that culminated in a World Series trip with the New York Yankees, Soto is poised to command a historic contract.

The baseball world is buzzing with speculation about where the 25-year-old superstar might land, and all signs point to a bidding war that could reshape the league for years to come.

16 17 18 pic.twitter.com/UEgf5Z2pWf

— Vladimir Guerrero Jr (@27vladdyjr) July 26, 2024

Following in Ohtani’s Footsteps

Soto’s potential contract is often compared to Shohei Ohtani’s record-breaking deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers last offseason. Ohtani signed a 10-year, $700 million agreement, setting a new standard for elite talent in MLB.

With Soto’s youth, consistency, and remarkable postseason pedigree, his contract is expected to mirror or even surpass Ohtani’s. Industry insiders anticipate offers in the $650–700 million range, cementing Soto’s status as a generational talent.

The New York Yankees and New York Mets are widely regarded as the frontrunners in the Soto sweepstakes. Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner is eager to retain the outfielder, whose dynamic hitting and clutch performances were pivotal to their World Series run.

Meanwhile, Mets owner Steve Cohen, known for his aggressive spending, is determined to bring Soto to Queens to rejuvenate his franchise.

For the Yankees, re-signing Soto would solidify their roster and ensure continued dominance in the highly competitive American League. For the Mets, landing Soto would signal a seismic shift in the balance of power in New York and the MLB as a whole.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr: Dark Horse Candidate

While New York’s teams dominate headlines, the Toronto Blue Jays have quietly emerged as a potential suitor.²

The Blue Jays, backed by the financial might of Rogers Communications, are motivated to make a bold move after falling short last offseason. Missing out on Shohei Ohtani still stings, and Juan Soto could be the perfect way to reassert their ambitions.

Adnan Virk, speaking on the Marty Caswell MartyTimeTV show, echoed this sentiment, suggesting that Toronto could shake up the market.

“They’re a much bigger market than people realize—they are Canada’s team,” Virk noted. “They could give him $650 million, see what happens, and try to win a World Series.”

The Implications for Toronto’s Stars

Signing Soto would come with its challenges for the Blue Jays, especially when it comes to retaining their existing stars.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette, two cornerstone players, are entering the final year of their contracts.

Extending both while absorbing Soto’s mega-deal would test the financial limits of even a well-resourced franchise like Toronto.

Virk emphasized this dilemma, stating, “If the Jays land Soto, they’ll likely have to lose Vlad or Bo—if not both. It’s a gamble, but one that could pay off with a championship.”

Vladimir Guerrero Jr: Fueling Toronto’s Ambition

• Toronto’s 2023 season was marked by inconsistency and underperformance, leaving fans and management frustrated.³
• The Blue Jays’ inability to capitalize on their talent-laden roster has added urgency to their offseason plans. Bringing Soto into the fold would send a clear message: Toronto is committed to winning at all costs.
• “The sting of last year hurts,” Virk remarked. “The Jays were willing to give Ohtani $600–700 million but failed to pivot effectively. This time, they can’t afford to miss.”
• What makes Soto such a prized asset is his combination of youth, consistency, and playoff experience. At just 25 years old, he already boasts a resume that includes multiple All-Star selections, a batting title, and a World Series championship.
• His career on-base percentage (.421) and plate discipline are virtually unmatched, making him a game-changing presence in any lineup.
• Soto’s marketability extends beyond his on-field prowess. He’s charismatic, globally recognized, and appeals to younger audiences—an increasingly vital demographic for MLB.
• For a team like the Blue Jays, whose reach spans an entire nation, Soto represents both athletic and commercial potential.

Challenges for Small-Market Teams

While big-market teams like the Yankees, Mets, and Blue Jays dominate discussions, smaller-market franchises face an uphill battle in pursuing Soto.

His price tag puts him out of reach for teams with limited payroll flexibility. This disparity underscores the growing financial divide in MLB, where elite free agents often gravitate toward wealthier teams.

However, surprises aren’t entirely out of the question. Teams like the San Diego Padres have shown a willingness to make bold investments in recent years, and a similar underdog story could unfold in the Soto saga.

The Bidding War Begins

As the offseason unfolds, expect intense competition for Soto’s services. Steinbrenner’s Yankees and Cohen’s Mets are primed to engage in a financial arms race, each determined to outbid the other. Toronto, with its unique position as a national team, offers an intriguing wildcard.

Regardless of the outcome, Soto’s decision will reverberate throughout MLB. His signing could redefine team dynamics, alter playoff landscapes, and set the tone for future free-agent negotiations.

For now, Soto remains tight-lipped about his preferences. Reports suggest he values both competitive opportunities and financial security, making his choice a blend of practical and aspirational considerations.

The timing of his decision will also be pivotal; an early signing could influence other free-agent moves, while a prolonged process could heighten the drama.

Will the Toronto Blue Jays Trade Vladimir Guerrero Jr.?

Vladimir Guerrero Jr., one of the most electrifying young talents in baseball, remains the cornerstone of the Toronto Blue Jays.

A homegrown superstar with unparalleled charisma and on-field prowess, Guerrero Jr. has emerged as the face of the franchise.

With his contract running through 2025, the Blue Jays have an opportunity to secure his services for years to come.

However, as negotiations loom, the possibility of a trade—a scenario unthinkable for many fans—has become a topic of speculation.

This article delves into the likelihood of such a move, the factors influencing the team’s decision, and potential outcomes if the Blue Jays decide to part ways with their star slugger.

A Generational Talent

Since making his MLB debut in 2019, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has lived up to the hype surrounding his name. The son of Hall of Famer Vladimir Guerrero, Jr.’s impact on the game has been monumental.

His 2021 season was particularly remarkable, as he belted 48 home runs, drove in 111 RBIs, and finished second in the MVP voting.

While his offensive numbers in 2023 dipped slightly, he still posted 30 home runs, 98 runs scored, and 103 RBIs, proving his consistent ability to perform at an elite level.

Beyond his statistics, Guerrero’s marketability makes him indispensable to the Blue Jays. He draws fans to the ballpark and serves as the team’s ambassador in Canada and globally. Losing him would not only weaken the lineup but also deal a blow to the franchise’s image.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr: The Contract Clock is Ticking

Guerrero is under team control through the 2025 season, which leaves Toronto two off-seasons to reach a long-term extension or consider alternatives.

Players of Guerrero’s caliber often seek contracts exceeding $300 million over 8–12 years.

While Toronto is not known for massive spending like teams such as the New York Yankees or Los Angeles Dodgers, it has invested in stars like George Springer and Kevin Gausman in recent years. Extending Guerrero would require an even greater financial commitment.

If negotiations stall or Guerrero seeks a deal beyond what Toronto is willing to offer, the front office could be forced to explore trade options to avoid losing him for nothing in free agency.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr: Giveaway

Vladimir Guerrero Jr organized giveaway program only for the U.S. and CA residents, which is sponsored by BA Sports Nutrition.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by BODYARMOR Canada (@drinkbodyarmor_ca)

The Argument Against a Trade

While there are reasons to consider trading Guerrero, the counterarguments are compelling. Keeping a player of his caliber ensures a consistent offensive threat, stabilizes the team’s identity, and maintains Toronto’s relevance in a competitive AL East.

Additionally, extending Guerrero would send a strong message to players and fans: the Blue Jays are committed to winning.

From a historical perspective, retaining stars has often been the better move. Teams that have built around franchise players—such as the Los Angeles Angels with Mike Trout or the St. Louis Cardinals with Paul Goldschmidt—have benefited from a strong identity and consistent competitiveness.

Blue Jays’ Long-Term Outlook

The decision to trade or extend Guerrero Jr. will shape Toronto’s future for years. If they choose to move him, the return must set the stage for sustained success.

If they extend him, the front office will need to carefully manage payroll to remain competitive while committing a significant portion to one player.

Toronto’s front office, led by General Manager Ross Atkins, has shown a willingness to take calculated risks.

Whether they double down on their commitment to Guerrero or decide to part ways, their decision will be scrutinized by fans and analysts alike.