Janis Roth: Is Randy Roth Killed her? How Did She Die? Married Life and More

Fatal Love with Lifetime’s ‘A Rose for Her Grave’ By going deeply into the horrifying story of Randy Roth, we gain a profound understanding of the ways in which emotional suppression and domestic violence may splinter entire lives into fragments

After all, the man who was previously a mechanic has not only been found guilty of the murder of his fourth wife Cynthia Roth in 1991, but he is also accused of having killed his second wife Janis Brasel Roth ten years earlier. Cynthia Roth’s death occurred in 1991.

Now, if you just want to find out more about the latter, with a specific focus on what exactly took place, its subsequent investigations, and its overall repercussions, we have you covered. So, if that’s all you want to do, we’ve got you covered.

Also Read: 

Janis Roth: Is Randy Roth Killed her?

Janis had a relatively difficult childhood in Texas, but by the time the 1980s rolled around, she had managed to carve out a successful existence for herself as a mother who was both fun-loving and committed to her role as a parent.

The fact is that she had gotten married to a serviceman before giving birth to their daughter Jalina while they were stationed in Germany, but once their marriage ended, she moved to Washington in order to start over and begin a new life. Jalina was born in Germany.

At that time, she was attending a social meet for parents without partners on Halloween in the year 1980. There, she met Randy Roth, who was a single father to a son at the time. After a whirlwind relationship in the month of March, they got married.

“Sometimes Janis leaped without thinking, making judgments based on emotions rather than on common reason,” noted true-crime novelist Ann Rule wrote in her book “A Rose for Her Grave.”

About her kid, she never wavered in the least from her unwavering resolve. Always in first place was Jalina. Janis loved her daughter so much that she was willing to give her own life for her.

As a result, it should not come as a surprise that she went along with her new husband when he insisted on taking out a life insurance policy on her as they bought a house. He stated that he wanted to be able to pay the mortgage even in the worst-case scenario, so he demanded that she take out a policy on him.

Nevertheless, on November 27, 1981, everything began to change after Janis and Randy made the decision to do the difficult 848-foot-high walk at Beacon Rock, which is located around three hours south of Seattle.

This is due to the fact that the second individual told the authorities that he was helpless and could only watch as his wife slipped and fell to her death when they were traversing a particularly challenging section of the trail.

It was a little bit weird that her body wasn’t located under the precise place where he said she’d tumbled from, but her passing was still deemed an accident due to the injuries she got during the fall. Her body wasn’t found under the specific region where he asserted she’d tumbled from.

Janis Roth: How Did She Die?

Because there were no witnesses to Janis’ death other than Randy, the authorities could only go off of his statements, which, to be honest, weren’t very helpful because he reportedly often contradicted himself. Since there were no witnesses to the death of Janis other than Randy, the authorities could only go off of his statements.

It was also exceedingly strange that he had her cremated the same day she passed away, made a claim on her $100,000 life insurance policy the following morning, and didn’t notify her loved ones of her passing for at least a week after she passed away.

These factors did, in the end, prompt the local authorities to investigate the route, but their findings revealed that it was extremely improbable that the young mother had fallen from the location that her spouse had identified.

Once Janis and Randy had gotten into their daily pattern, friends and relatives of Janis revealed that Randy had lost much of the charm and tenderness that she had first liked in him.

This happened very suddenly once they had settled into their daily routine. Although though he was said to have become emotionally distant, indifferent, and aloof, he still wanted to adopt Jalina after his wife passed away.

Nevertheless, he was unable to do so since his late wife had made arrangements for the daughter to be reared by relatives in Texas. In addition, it is essential to point out that he moved houses rather quickly, despite the claim that he had her insured to assist his immediate brood in remaining in the home they had purchased for as long as possible.

Because of this, there was a plausible suspicion that Randy had purposefully pushed Janis from the dangerously high cliff, but the lack of proof precluded the investigators from ever charging him with her murder.

Janis Roth: Married Life

In spite of this, his private history was once again pushed into the public front in 1991 when his fourth wife, Cynthia Roth, passed away under strange circumstances while on an outing to appreciate nature.

It did not help matters that he had a history of insurance fraud, that his brother David Roth was already serving time for murder (David Roth had killed a hitchhiker in 1977), and that he responded similarly to when Janis had passed away.

Randy was, once again, the only witness who remained aloof. He provided conflicting accounts of the circumstances surrounding Cynthia’s passing, had her cremated as swiftly as possible, and failed to inform her family while simultaneously cashing in on her $400,000 life insurance policy.

But, this time around, over three months after her death by drowning on July 23, 1991, local Seattle police arrested him on suspicion of his fourth spouse’s murder and executed a search warrant on his property.

Also Read:

Janis Roth: Death

This occurred in Seattle. What was found was a poem that Cynthia had written not long before she passed away. In it, she detailed 44 characteristics of herself that her beau disliked, as well as how their relationship was unhealthy.

As a result of this poetry, grim testimony from past companions, and specifics of Janis’s destiny being addressed in court, he was found guilty of both theft and murder in the year 1992.

In the beginning of their relationship, his ex-girlfriend claimed that he was “the man every woman dreams of.” However, nearly as soon as they were exclusive, he changed into a cold, controlling, and violent person.

Another one of his exes gave testimony that verified his pattern of malice and pressure to get life insurance policies. She claimed that he ended their relationship after discovering that she is a cancer survivor and was therefore probably unable to be insured.

As if this were not enough, Randy’s third wife came out and stated that she had divorced him out of fear immediately following an incident in which she was certain that his intention was to murder her.

She claimed that she had done this shortly after the event. She said that while they were on the Skykomish River, her husband abruptly attempted to steer their inflatable raft through the rapids and towards jagged rocks that were pointing toward her.

This information is documented in the court documents. Because of this, in the end, Rudolph “Randy” Roth was given a sentence of fifty years in prison for the murder of Cynthia Roth; nevertheless, he has never been caught, charged, tried, or convicted in connection to Janis’ unsolved death.

Janis Roth: More Details

• Lifetime’s Ripped from the Headlines movies are known for producing storylines that are inspired by real-life criminal cases. The most recent offering from the network, titled A Rose for Her Grave, is also based on a true event.
• Chrishell Stause, who starred in Selling Sunset, plays the lead role of Lori, a woman who is skeptical of the drowning death of her closest friend. It ended up that she had good reason to be concerned.
• The book by the same name written by Ann Rule is a true crime account that relates the narrative of Randy Roth’s four marriages, two of which ended in deaths that were allegedly accidental.
• Cynthia Baumgartner, who played the role of Cindy in the film, was Roth’s fourth wife and her away in 1991 after drowning in Lake Sammamish. Lori’s companion was known as Cindy. His second wife, Janis Miranda, passed away from injuries sustained in a fall off of Beacon Rock in Washington state ten years previously.
• According to reports, Roth was the only person present when either of the women were in their final moments. According to the Seattle Times, a third wife who survived the incident claimed that she believed Roth attempted to capsize a raft that they were traveling on down a river.
• In the case of Cynthia, Roth was found guilty of murder in the first degree. According to what is written in the Times, Roth tried to cash out the life insurance policies on both of his wives after they passed away; nonetheless, he was found not guilty of killing Janis.

Also Read: