Dominik Mysterio’s actions over the past few weeks suggest that change is imminent for The Judgment Day
Whether his interest in Penta was genuine or merely a clever diversion remains unclear, but his clandestine meetings with Karrion Kross cannot be ignored.
With cryptic social media posts, rejected proposals, and mounting distrust, WWE fans are being treated to a slow-burning storyline filled with intrigue, deception, and high stakes.
One thing is certain: Dominik Mysterio’s ambitions have the potential to reshape the very fabric of The Judgment Day, setting the stage for explosive developments in the weeks to come.
The brewing hostility between Finn Balor and Dominik Mysterio is shaping up to be one of the marquee stories heading into WrestleMania 41. WWE has expertly laid the foundation—a mix of personal betrayal, faction implosion, and individual ambition.
With creative storytelling, compelling character arcs, and the possibility of a show-stealing match, fans are in for a memorable showdown.
Whether Balor reasserts his dominance or Dominik completes his transformation into a bona fide main event star, one thing is certain: WrestleMania 41 could mark a turning point in both superstars’ careers.
Also Read: Dominik Mysterio Bio, Age, Career, Net Worth, Personal Life And More
Table of Contents
Dominik Mysterio’s Quest to Expand The Judgment Day
A New Alliance on the Horizon?
Over the past year, The Judgment Day has been one of WWE’s most dominant heel factions, led by Finn Balor, Damian Priest, Rhea Ripley, and Dominik Mysterio.1
Their unity and ruthlessness have made them a force to be reckoned with on both RAW and premium live events.
However, recent events suggest that Dominik Mysterio may be looking to shake up the group’s dynamic by adding new blood to the faction—an idea that has sparked tension within the group, particularly with Balor.
In the latest episode of RAW, Dominik Mysterio took a bold step by suggesting the inclusion of none other than Penta, one-half of the Lucha Brothers and a renowned figure in the wrestling world.
Known for his ferocity, in-ring prowess, and masked charisma, Penta would undoubtedly bring a unique flavor to The Judgment Day.
However, Finn Balor was quick to reject the idea. His concern? Penta, much like Dominik, has set his sights on the Intercontinental Championship, currently held by Gunther.
Balor questioned Dom’s loyalty, suggesting that Dirty Dom’s push for Penta was self-serving, adding another competitor into the title picture instead of strengthening the faction’s hold on the gold.
https://t.co/CTeZqIV3Rk pic.twitter.com/HVomnYi5Oz
— Dominik (@DomMysterio35) March 8, 2025
Carlito’s Taunt: An Underlying Hint?
Carlito, never one to shy away from stirring the pot, taunted Dominik during a backstage segment. He sarcastically questioned whether Dom even watches the shows, highlighting how obvious Penta’s interest in the Intercontinental Title was.
This jab not only embarrassed Dom but also planted seeds of doubt regarding his intentions within The Judgment Day.
Was Dominik genuinely unaware of Penta’s ambitions, or was he purposefully distracting Finn Balor and the rest of the faction? The conversation raised eyebrows among fans and superstars alike, leaving many to wonder whether Dom had ulterior motives behind the suggestion.
Though he didn’t directly name Dominik or The Judgment Day, his words implied that he’s been engaged in behind-the-scenes negotiations—likely referencing the interactions with Dirty Dom.
Given Kross’ history of using social media to further his psychological warfare, the tweet felt like a deliberate breadcrumb left for fans to connect the dots. It’s no secret that Kross thrives in dark, manipulative environments, making him an ideal fit for a faction like The Judgment Day.
Dominik Mysterio’s Power Play: Is He Trying to Usurp Balor?
At the heart of the speculation lies a fascinating question—why is Dominik Mysterio so intent on expanding the group? Some fans believe that Dom might be trying to consolidate power within The Judgment Day, possibly positioning himself as a more influential figure at the expense of Finn Balor.
If he successfully recruits someone like Kross, whose intimidating presence and championship pedigree cannot be ignored, Dom could bolster his standing within the faction.
This move could potentially set the stage for internal conflict, with Balor feeling threatened by Dom’s growing alliances.
Analyzing the faction’s aesthetic and core values, Karrion Kross seems tailor-made to join. His dark persona, psychological warfare, and violent in-ring style complement the broodiness of The Judgment Day.
Moreover, his partner, Scarlett, could add another layer of mystique to the group, serving as a female counterpart alongside Rhea Ripley.
Kross’ addition could reestablish him as a dominant force on the main roster, after a stop-start tenure since his return to WWE. His partnership with a faction already wielding significant influence would give him fresh storylines, rivalries, and perhaps even title opportunities.
The Karrion Kross Connection: Hidden in Plain Sight
While all eyes were initially focused on Dominik’s conversation about Penta, another intriguing development quietly unfolded on RAW over the past two weeks. Keen viewers noticed that Dominik Mysterio was seen talking backstage with none other than Karrion Kross.
Kross, a former NXT Champion, has long been associated with darkness, control, and cryptic mind games—qualities that would align perfectly with the aesthetic of The Judgment Day.
While the nature of their discussions wasn’t revealed, the timing raised significant speculation. Notably, the most recent episode showed Dom and Kross talking in hushed tones as Dakota Kai made her entrance.
Could it be that Penta was merely a smokescreen, diverting attention away from Dominik’s real recruitment target?
Adding to the intrigue, Karrion Kross took to Twitter shortly after RAW aired, posting a vague but ominous message suggesting ongoing talks about an alliance.
Balor and Dominik Mysterio’s Relationship on the Brink?
With Finn Balor dismissing Dominik’s suggestions outright, there’s potential for cracks to emerge in The Judgment Day’s otherwise solid unity.2
Dominik’s persistence, coupled with Balor’s growing distrust, could eventually lead to tensions boiling over.
Could we see a scenario where Balor and Dom’s partnership dissolves into an all-out feud?
A power struggle between the two could provide compelling television, pitting Balor’s veteran experience against Dirty Dom’s growing ambition and underhanded tactics.
The Role of Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley
Interestingly, neither Damian Priest nor Rhea Ripley have publicly commented on Dom’s recent recruitment efforts. Their silence adds another layer of mystery.
Priest, as the current World Heavyweight Champion, may prefer to focus on retaining his title, leaving the faction’s leadership debates to unfold without his interference—for now.
Meanwhile, Ripley, the faction’s enforcer and often its voice of reason, might eventually weigh in to mediate or take sides. Her stance could play a pivotal role in determining whether the group stays united or fractures under the weight of internal competition and mistrust.
Where Does Penta Stand?
One question that remains unanswered is whether Penta himself was aware of the recruitment discussion.
Dominik never interacted with him on screen, which raises the possibility that Penta’s involvement was entirely speculative—used as a red herring by Dom to conceal his true plans.
While fans may fantasize about Penta’s brutal, high-flying style meshing with The Judgment Day, it appears more likely that his name was a pawn in Dominik’s larger strategy.
That said, should WWE decide to capitalize on fan interest, future interactions between Penta and the faction can’t be ruled out entirely.
Long-Term Implications for The Judgment Day
Should Karrion Kross officially join the ranks of The Judgment Day, the ripple effects would extend beyond the faction itself.
Rivalries across the RAW roster would shift dramatically, with superstars like Cody Rhodes, Sami Zayn, and Jey Uso potentially facing an even more dangerous version of the group.
Additionally, the internal power dynamics within the faction would become a central focus. Balor, Priest, Ripley, and Mysterio have long maintained a balance of control and chaos—adding Kross could disrupt that equilibrium, leading to unexpected betrayals, new alliances, and possibly even a civil war within the group.
Dominik Mysterio vs. Finn Balor: Brewing Feud Headed for WrestleMania 41?
The WWE Universe has witnessed tensions simmer within The Judgment Day over recent months.3
One particular dynamic capturing fans’ attention is the increasingly strained relationship between Dominik Mysterio and Finn Balor.
Recent episodes of RAW and SmackDown have sowed the seeds for a full-blown rivalry, setting up a potential blockbuster showdown at WrestleMania 41.
Cracks in The Judgment Day Foundation
When The Judgment Day formed, their dark charisma and ruthless tactics quickly propelled them to the top of WWE’s heel hierarchy.
Led by veterans like Finn Balor and Rhea Ripley, and featuring rising stars like Dominik Mysterio and Damian Priest, the group exuded dominance. However, cracks began to appear as the group’s ambitions and egos clashed.
Tensions particularly intensified between Dirty Dom and Balor. Mysterio’s increasing boldness, combined with his knack for inadvertently interfering in Balor’s matches, has not gone unnoticed.
The faction’s once-tight unity is now fragile, with the Balor-Mysterio tension becoming more pronounced by the week.
The “Snake” Accusation: Balor’s Breaking Point
The most recent flashpoint occurred when Dominik suggested adding Penta to The Judgment Day. Balor, clearly frustrated, didn’t mince words—he labeled Dirty Dom a “snake.”
This confrontation was more than just an offhand insult; it highlighted Balor’s simmering distrust of Mysterio. The accusation ignited chatter across social media, with fans speculating whether Balor’s patience had finally run out.
For WWE creative, this moment appears to be a deliberate signal. Finn Balor, known for his stoic demeanor, doesn’t often let emotions dictate his actions. So when he publicly calls out a stablemate, it hints at deeper storylines brewing.
Dominik Mysterio’s Costly Interference
The relationship deteriorated further when Dominik attempted to assist Balor in his match against Bron Breakker.
Instead of turning the tide in Balor’s favor, Mysterio’s interference backfired, costing The Demon King the match.
Was it mere incompetence or subtle sabotage? While Mysterio’s intentions were likely genuine, Balor’s trust in him has been irreparably damaged.
The timing couldn’t be worse, as The Judgment Day’s power within WWE is threatened by both internal instability and external challengers like Breakker.
View this post on Instagram
Seeds of Rivalry: WWE’s Slow-Burn Storytelling
WWE’s strength lies in its ability to weave long-term storytelling, and the Mysterio-Balor arc is a masterclass example. For months, subtle hints—side-eyes, cryptic promos, missed tags—have painted a picture of growing discord.
The creative team, led by Triple H, seems to be laying the groundwork meticulously. With WrestleMania 41 just months away, the storyline is positioned to climax at The Show of Shows.
This slow-burn strategy ensures maximum fan investment by the time the two finally collide.
Finn Balor: The Veteran Feeling the Heat
Finn Balor has been at the top of the wrestling world for years. As a former Universal Champion, Balor commands respect.
Yet, within The Judgment Day, he’s found his leadership challenged, particularly by the younger and brasher Dominik Mysterio.
Balor’s frustrations stem not only from Mysterio’s growing independence but also from the potential threat he poses to Balor’s standing in WWE.
Balor may soon resort to his darker side—the Demon King persona—to reclaim dominance and put Mysterio in his place.
Also Read: WrestleMania 40 Rumors: Is a SmackDown Star Planning to Replace Dominik Mysterio?
