Table of Contents
Grand Jury Decision on Chad Read’s Fatal Shooting
The local community is grappling with uncertainty in the aftermath of the tragic death of Chad Read. Residents are seeking clarity on the legal proceedings surrounding Kyle Carruth, whose involvement in the incident on November 5, 2021, raises numerous questions about potential consequences.1
Grand Jury Verdict
- At the heart of the matter is the decision of a grand jury, convened by the Attorney General’s Office, to not indict Kyle Carruth.
- This verdict comes after a meticulous examination of evidence, including eyewitness accounts, testimonies from Read’s family, and undisclosed material.
- Despite the video footage circulating that depicts the heated confrontation leading to Read’s death, the Special Grand Jury concluded that criminal charges against Carruth were not warranted.
Reactions and Legal Actions
Following the grand jury’s decision, Jennifer Read, Chad Read’s widow, expressed profound disappointment in the criminal justice system.
She criticized Carruth’s introduction of a firearm into an altercation he was not initially involved in and disseminated mobile phone footage capturing the dispute and its fatal climax.
Wrongful Death Lawsuit
In addition to voicing dissatisfaction, Jennifer Read initiated a wrongful death lawsuit against Kyle Carruth, seeking reparations amounting to $50 million.
This legal action underscores her concerns regarding the perceived failings of the criminal justice system.
I want your thoughts if this was justified or not. LUBBOCK, Texas (KCBD) – The attorney for Chad Read’s widow released a statement and video of the shooting that killed 54-year-old Chad Read on Nov. 5. Along with the video, the attorney supplied a petition filed on Wednesday… pic.twitter.com/B5U2usFrc5
— ค•ค•Ր૦Ո ™ (@dunmesedupaaron) January 22, 2024
Ongoing Inquiries and Public Interest
The Texas Attorney General’s Office has taken note of the heightened public interest and is conducting further inquiries.2
This reflects the complexities and challenges in securing justice for Chad Read and the broader implications of the case.
Unknown Legal Status of Kyle Carruth
Details about Kyle Carruth’s current whereabouts and legal status remain unknown. The community and those closely monitoring the situation are eagerly waiting for updates.
The video evidence of the dispute, leading up to the shooting, has sparked debates over the legal system’s approach to claims of self-defense.
Shift to Civil Court
Post the grand jury’s decision, attention has shifted to the civil court, where ongoing litigation continues to raise questions about accountability and legal interpretations.
The community anticipates further developments in both the civil lawsuit and any findings from the Texas Attorney General’s ongoing criminal investigation.
Legal Proceedings and Public Scrutiny
The intersection of legal proceedings and public scrutiny in this case demonstrates the significant impact it has had, not only on the individuals directly involved but also on the wider community seeking closure and justice for the events that transpired.
Unfolding Legal Narrative
As the situation evolves, all eyes remain on the unfolding legal narrative.
This narrative promises to illuminate the intricacies of the law and its application in this poignant and contentious case.
The Death of Chad Read: A Comprehensive Timeline
The tragic incident involving Chad Read’s death on November 5, 2021, has unfolded a complex series of events. This comprehensive timeline aims to document and organize the key developments surrounding the case.3
Initial Incident – November 5, 2021
Location: 2100 block of 90th Street
On this fateful day, Chad Read was shot and killed during a verbal altercation over child custody.
The Lubbock Police Department responded to the scene following a distress call, and one person was found dead.
Subsequent Developments
November 6, 2021
The identity of the deceased was revealed as 54-year-old Chad Read.
The police indicated a verbal altercation related to a domestic incident turned physical. No arrests had been made, and the investigation was ongoing.
November 9, 2021
Obtaining the police report, it was revealed that the shooter had close ties with a State District Judge in Lubbock.
November 10, 2021
In response to concerns about transparency, the Lubbock Police Department released a statement on the shooting.
Simultaneously, the Lubbock County District Attorney’s Office recused itself due to a potential witness conflict.
November 16, 2021
The case files were transferred from the Lubbock Police Department to the Texas Attorney General’s Office.
November 19 – 22, 2021
Reports surfaced that State District Judge Ann-Marie Carruth, with ties to the shooter, filed an affidavit related to her ongoing divorce case. Court records were sealed, generating intrigue around the case.
November 24, 2021
Chad’s widow, Jennifer Read, released a cellphone video of the deadly confrontation, alleging a conspiracy to assault or murder Chad. The shooter’s attorney claimed self-defense.
November 27, 2021
Jennifer Read, accompanied by her attorney, spoke to ABC’s Good Morning America, explaining the motive behind releasing the video.
November 30, 2021
Jennifer Read filed a $50 million wrongful death lawsuit against Kyle Carruth, accusing him of unnecessary escalation and wrongful death.
December 6, 2021
Chad Read’s mother and children filed a separate lawsuit against Kyle Carruth, seeking punitive damages for negligence.
December 7, 2021
The Texas Attorney General’s Office announced the initiation of a criminal investigation into the shooting death.
December 8, 2021
The law firm representing Chad Read’s family held a press conference, where Jennifer Read appealed for action from law enforcement and the Attorney General.
December 30, 2021
Kyle Carruth filed court records in his defense, admitting to shooting and killing Chad Read.
January 5, 2022
Jennifer Read’s lawsuit for custody of Chad Read’s children was dismissed due to Texas law requirements.
March 29, 2022
Jennifer Read revealed on social media that the case was presented before a grand jury.
March 31, 2022
The Texas Attorney General’s Office announced that the grand jury voted against indicting Kyle Carruth, leading to disappointment from Chad Read’s family.
This comprehensive timeline provides a structured overview of the unfolding events surrounding the tragic death of Chad Read, capturing legal, investigative, and personal dimensions of the case.
Fatal Shooting of Chad Read and Suspect Kyle Carruth: A Tragic Incident Unfolds
- Chad Read, a 54-year-old father from Lubbock, tragically lost his life in a fatal shooting that occurred on November 5.
- The incident unfolded outside his ex-wife’s house during a confrontation involving the former couple and the woman’s boyfriend, identified as William Kyle Carruth.
- This overview delves into the details surrounding the case, shedding light on the individuals involved and the events leading up to the tragic incident.
Child Custody Dispute:
- The confrontation between Chad Read and his ex-wife, Christina Read, was captured in a video released by Jennifer Read, Chad’s current wife.
- The argument centered around a dispute over child custody, specifically the absence of one of the former couple’s sons at a court-ordered time.
- Tensions escalated as Chad confronted Christina, leading to a heated exchange about their son’s whereabouts and the court-ordered deadline.
Read More:Blake Anderson Obituary: What Happened To Him? Tragic Death, Fatal Accident and Tribute
Confrontation Escalates:
Chad Read, angered by the situation, threatened to subpoena multiple individuals, including Kyle Carruth’s ex-wife, Judge Anne-Marie Carruth. As the confrontation intensified, Kyle, who had previously instructed Chad to leave the property, emerged from the home with a rifle.4
The two engaged in a verbal and physical struggle, culminating in Kyle firing shots at Chad, resulting in his tragic death.
Background and Recent Marriage of Chad Read:
Chad Read’s obituary revealed details about his background and recent marriage to Jennifer Read. A Lubbock native, Chad was described as a true entrepreneur who returned to the city in 2000 to raise a family.
The obituary made no mention of his ex-wife, Christina Read, but highlighted his recent marriage to Jennifer on September 4, 2021.
Anne-Marie Carruth’s Involvement:
- Anne-Marie Carruth, a district court judge, played a significant role in the aftermath of the incident.
- Court filings revealed that she had married Kyle Carruth in 2008, separated from him in July 2021, and filed for divorce in September.
- The affidavit filed by Anne-Marie indicated concerns about Kyle’s mental state, and Lubbock County District Attorney Sunshine Stanek recused her office from the case due to the suspect’s relation to a Lubbock County elected official.
Legal Actions and Lawsuits:
- Jennifer Read, through her attorney Anthony Buzbee, filed a petition alleging that Christina Read’s decisions endangered the well-being of her children.
- Additionally, Jennifer filed a $50 million wrongful death lawsuit against Kyle Carruth, citing negligence, civil assault, and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
- Despite a grand jury’s decision not to indict Carruth on criminal charges, the Read family pursued two wrongful death lawsuits in civil court.
Self-Defense Claim and Legal Response:
- Kyle Carruth’s attorney, David M. Guinn, argued that the shooting was an act of self-defense.
- Guinn contended that Texans have the right to brandish a firearm for protection.
- Despite the grand jury’s decision not to press criminal charges, the Read family’s attorney, Tony Buzbee, expressed dissatisfaction with the justice system and vowed to aggressively pursue Jennifer Read’s claims in civil court.
Chad Read Obituary
On November 5, 2023, Lubbock, Texas, resident Chad Read, aged 54, tragically passed away in the aftermath of a domestic incident involving a terrible shooting. The news of his sudden demise has left the community, friends, and family in deep grief.
Read More: Dakota Piper (Obituary: How Did Kenzie Elizabeth Brother Dakota Piper Die? Family Mourns and More
Circumstances Surrounding Chad Read’s Death
The circumstances surrounding Chad Read’s death have sent shockwaves through the community.
The incident, rooted in a domestic conflict, has brought attention to the complexities and consequences of such conflicts. The impact on Chad Read’s life and those around him is evident, shedding light on the profound effects of interpersonal disputes.
Chad Read’s Legacy
In addition to being a victim of a distressing event, Chad Read is remembered as a devoted family man. His passing has left behind Jennifer Read, a grieving widow who is currently entangled in a custody dispute over their children.
The Tragedy Unfolds
Video Evidence
A video capturing the Chad Read case provides a poignant visual representation of the fatal altercation that led to his untimely death. The images portrayed in the video contribute to the collective understanding of the incident.
Aftermath and Reflection
The aftermath of this tragedy serves as a sobering reminder of the significance of interpersonal disputes and the far-reaching effects they may have on the lives of those left behind.
The community now awaits future judicial processes, hoping for clarity and closure as the specifics of the incident come to light.
Obituary as a Reflection
Chad Read’s obituary becomes a moving example of the transience of life.
It prompts contemplation on the importance of confronting and resolving disputes to uphold the value of human life and prevent similar tragic incidents from occurring in the future.
Also Read: Dakota Piper: Obituary, Death Cause, What Happened To Her? Age And Family
